Laduma Today: free PSL stats by Laduma Analytics

Open Laduma Today: live scores, log and fixtures

What has gone wrong at Polokwane City?

A Season of Highs, Lows, and Statistical Realities

Friday 28 March 2025 · 4 min read · By LadumaAnalytics

Early Season Momentum and Overperformance

Polokwane City started the 2024/25 campaign impressively, collecting 20 points from a possible 33 in their first 11 games. This fast start saw them riding high in the league table, exceeding their Expected Points (xPts) for most of the season. However, as the campaign progressed, the effects of statistical regression began to take hold. Now, with 33 points from 22 games, their actual performance has aligned more closely with their xPts of 32, highlighting the often inevitable correction of early-season overachievement.

The team's last victory came on February 1st, a 1-0 win over Chippa United. Since then, results have stalled, causing them to slip from third to sixth place in the standings. Head coach Phuti Mohafe had previously warned his players not to take their lofty league position for granted, an echo of the warnings he once voiced. Nonetheless, three more wins (from 8 games) would see them reach 40 points - a mark that has historically secured a Top 8 finish.

Comparing Performance with Last Season

Looking at their progress compared to last season, City’s trajectory is mixed. In the 2023/24 campaign, they finished eighth with 39 points, scoring 21 goals and conceding 27. The table below compares the points accumulated across 10-game spells across the two seasons. They came out of the blocks flying, collecting points at a fast rate, and then slightly slumped towards the end of the campaign. Their recent slump raises questions about that being repeated.

Season 1 - 10 11 - 20 21 - 30

2023/24 15 pts 12 pts 12 pts

2024/25 17 pts 14 pts tbc

Underlying Issues: xG and Attacking Efficiency

One key concern is Polokwane City’s attacking production. Last season, they reached the Top8 despite scoring just 21 goals, the fewest for a Top 8 team in PSL history. Yet, a high shot conversion rate aided their strong early-season results rather than sustained attacking dominance. They converted 10% of their chances in Q1 (5th best in the league), but have regressed massively to 5% shot conversion, the worst in the league in that time, The team’s struggles have become more apparent as their finishing tails off to the mean. It mirrors a similar pattern to last season where they started strong and then went on to collect 12 points in their final 10 league matches.

The xG graph tells the same story of their season.

  • The green line represents rolling xG, showing the team’s chance creation.

  • The red line represents rolling xGA (Expected Goals Against), a proxy to their defensive stability.

  • Green shading appears when xG surpasses xGA, signifying attacking superiority.

  • Red shading emerges when xGA exceeds xG, marking defensive frailty.

Recently, the graph has shown more red than green, suggesting a downturn in form. Whether this is due to injuries, tactical inefficiencies, or fixture difficulty remains a point of analysis.

Shot Analysis and Conversion Concerns

City currently ranks eighth in total shots taken across the league, with an overall season shot conversion rate of 7%, slightly below the league average. You only have to look at their leading shooter, Oswin Appollis, for the symptoms. He has taken 47 shots but has converted just 4% of them, netting twice. The next-highest shooter, Bonginkosi Dlamini, has managed only 18 shots.

This data highlights inefficiencies in Polokwane City’s attacking play. While Appollis is a high-volume shooter, his conversion rate suggests either poor shot selection or a lack of clinical finishing. Without a reliable goal-scorer, the team’s struggles in front of goal could continue.

Final Thoughts

City’s season has been a classic tale of overperformance, statistical correction, and recent struggles. While their early form propelled them into the Top 3, the slump has seen them fall to sixth. With a few more wins, a Top 8 finish remains within reach, but key concerns around xG, shot efficiency, attacking conversion, and defensive stability need to be addressed.

Whether Mohafe can reverse their downturn and secure a strong finish will likely depend on tactical adjustments and improvements in attacking play. The next few games will be crucial in determining whether this team can solidify its place among the league’s elite or fade further down the standings.

PS. Look out for our new website coming soon...

Get the Laduma Analytics newsletter

PSL analysis like this in your inbox. Subscribe free

More articles

  • Zones of Control
    (Yet) another way to measure “dominance”? Fri 20 Nov 2026 · 4 min read
  • Milford FC and Kruger United adjust.
    How the newly promoted teams are finding their feet in the top flight. Sat 7 Nov 2026 · 5 min read
  • Soweto derby preview..
    Pirates host Chiefs as defensive numbers cross for the first time in 26 years. Sat 31 Oct 2026 · 4 min read
  • Ocean’s Eleven
    Measuring attacking involvement beyond goals and assists. Sat 24 Oct 2026 · 6 min read
  • PSL Progress Report
    How PSL teams are performing in both boxes compared to last season? Sat 17 Oct 2026 · 4 min read

All articles