Teams come and go in the PSL.
In the 30 seasons since 96/97, there have been 49 “genuine” promotions from the lower division (excluding status sales and renames). Of these, 35% lasted only one season in the top-flight, and 51% were gone within two years (most of them relegated on the field). Whether the PSL’s revolving door signals a league of equal opportunity or one lacking stability, you can’t argue the fact that life at the top table is often fleeting. Recently Orbit College and Cape Town Spurs lasted one season, Magesi just two. Promoted sides finish 13th on average, and only two of the 49 have ever made the Top 5.
Many feared for this season’s two newcomers, Milford FC and Kruger United, the latter mostly after an indifferent start. But they both look to have steadied their early nerves, and are playing better than some of the more established teams. While there is some difference in their league positions (4th v 9th) and goal differences, their trajectories look positive one third into the campaign.
Milford FC
Milford had already been thrust into the limelight after knocking Kaizer Chiefs out of the 2024 Nedbank Cup. Their semi-final run last season and winning the gruelling promotional playoffs meant they started the season as the more well-known side to the average fan.
They opened the campaign with a 2-0 loss to the defending champions Orlando Pirates, but have lost just one of nine league games since, and even that was against defending African champions Sundowns. The sample size is small, but the rolling xG chart shows how they’ve quickly fixed both defence and attack, with the two matches against Sundowns and Pirates the only occasions they leaked more than 2xG. The 5-1 win over 10-man Richards Bay was significant in that it lifted their attack closer to 1.5xG per game, while simultaneously heaping the pressure on their KZN neighbours.

On the ball, Milford have shown composure, building play patiently. 53% average ball possession is 4th highest in the league, but that only tells half the story. Most of their passes are short, and their possessions go on for a while compared to other teams. They have climbed to 4th spot, on a trajectory towards CAF places.

That is only if they can sustain being ahead on some of these numbers - their xG difference, for example, needs improvement and ranks 11th. A Top 8 qualification looks more attainable - only 24% of promoted teams have reached the Top 8. Already 18 points from 10 games puts them in the top 10% for a newcomer in PSL history. In a cautious season where only seven teams have managed to win back-to-back games (and that includes Milford), Xanti Pupuma’s side may have enough to maintain that positive balance in xG.
Kruger United
Kruger have made a less impressive start, particularly in terms of results. The club’s promotion from the first division was built on a sharp attacking unit that bagged 50 goals, the most by a champion in 10 years. But even that attack covered for a leaky defence (8th best in the division). Both were never going to translate well into the Premiership. As such, Kruger found the going tough at first.

At the end of August, Kruger were bottom of the table and winless. The 2-1 defeat to Milford after taking the lead was the most jarring, hinting at a naivety that needed a quick fix. And some of the fixes, especially on the defensive front, are helping. Shots conceded per game have gone down from 15 to 11, while xG per shot conceded has stayed the same. The numbers suggest keeping play higher up the pitch has helped on both ends, but nine games in, it’s more suggestive than proof.

Like Milford, facing the champions so early skewed some numbers that would otherwise look positive. The trajectory on both charts is upwards. For safety, both points and Expected Points are well within reach. Kruger have done back-to-back wins ahead of teams above them in the table (Chippa and Stellenbosch), and teams that are more established (Arrows & TS Galaxy), which make their coach’s comments worth taking seriously.
“I told the boys that they should not worry about the pressure from the outside … but they must be able to handle the pressure we put on ourselves internally because we have big ambitions this season and that is to be in the top eight.” - Kruger United coach Abram Mongoya to SABC
The internal objectives are public, and while they are not yet making an xG surplus (a bare minimum for such ambitions), the signs look promising.
This newsletter was sponsored by Easybet, whose support made this edition possible. Use code LAD50 at Easybet: http://bit.ly/LAD50

