Laduma Today: free PSL stats by Laduma Analytics

Open Laduma Today: live scores, log and fixtures

Evaluating: PSL Keepers beyond clean sheets

A data deep-dive into DSTV Prem Goalkeepers in 2023/24

Wednesday 26 June 2024 · 8 min read · By LadumaAnalytics

On Sunday 23 June 2024, Ronwen Williams was crowned the PSL’s Footballer of the Season, in addition to his Goalkeeper of the Season award. Ali Sangare and Sage Stephens were nominated alongside him for the latter, and few would begrudge one or both of Stanley Nwabali and Darren Keet if they had been nominees. The goalkeeper position is unique in that on the one hand, they are the only players on the field allowed to use their hands, and their events (saves, catches, punches, and even drops) can easily be assessed in addition to what they may do with their feet. But in today’s game, keepers are also called upon to build up play, invite opponents to press, and even dominate their boxes. We need to look at all of these, and more in our attempts to evaluate this unique position. So, let's dig into some of the (available) numbers to see the best-performing keepers in the league this season beyond clean sheets, and the cases for and against each of the three nominees.

Clean sheets

The natural first step when it comes to assessing goalkeepers is clean sheets (something our judges probably looked at). While it is a good starting point, it can be hard to judge the instances where other factors had more to do with the clean sheet than the keeper. A defender’s last-ditch clearance may be the difference between a clean sheet and conceding, or there may be games where the opposition has no shots on target (this happened 18 times this season, including twice for Sundowns (Onyango) and thrice for Stellies (Stephens)). That said, Williams is the league leader for clean sheets, with 15 in 22 games.

Most clean sheets this season:

  • 15 - Williams

  • 12 - Sapunga

  • 11 - Sangare, Stephens, Keet

  • 10 - Mothwa,, Nwabali

Likewise, goals conceded is one of the simpler things to look at. For this, we went on a per90-minute basis to fairly evaluate players who conceded a few goals but also played fewer matches.

The Top 5 keepers for goals conceded per 90 minutes:

  • 0.18 - Onyango

  • 0.36 - Williams

  • 0.62 - Sapunga

  • 0.65 - Masuluke

  • 0.74 - Sangaré

    *Stephens 0.83 (10th)

Shot stopping

Despite the goalkeeper role evolving over the years, shot-stopping remains one of the most important KPIs for a keeper. As such, saves and save percentages are the most commonly used terms you’ll hear when keepers are assessed. When considering absolute save numbers, a good practice is to take into account the volume of shots faced. This season, for example, the five keepers that faced the most shots were also the top five keepers for the number of saves made (though in a different ordering). Last season, four of the five most targeted keepers were in the Top 5 for saves. Put simply, the most targeted keepers will have more opportunities to boost their save numbers.

The Top 5 keepers for saves:

  • 76 - Nwabali

  • 71 - Akpeyi

  • 63 - Goss

  • 60 - Magoola

  • 58 - Keet

    • Sangare (7th), Stephens (12th), Williams (14th)

None of the PSL’s nominees are on this list. And while some keepers don’t make too many saves in raw number terms, it’s worth pointing out the proportion of shots on target that they save (irrespective of the volume).

The Top 5 keepers for save percentage (shots on target faced in brackets) :

  • 86% - Onyango (7)

  • 84% - Petersen (37)

  • 83% - Masuluke (24)

  • 82% - Williams (47)

  • 80% - Sapunga (65)

    • Sangare 77% (8th), Stephens 70% (21st)

The chart below is another helpful way of looking at shot-stopping. It pits saves per 90 against shots on target faced per 90 for goalkeepers who played at least 450 minutes. The bottom left quadrant shows keepers who faced a few shots and made a few saves (Onyango, Williams, Buthelezi, Chaine, etc). The top right shows keepers who faced many shots and made many saves (Petersen, Masuluke, Watenga, Nwabali, etc), while the bottom quadrant is filled with keepers who face many shots but face few saves.

Aerial ability

Beyond saves and clean sheets, we can also look at goalkeepers’ aerial abilities and appraise their effectiveness with high balls. A catch (claims in some circles) is defined simply as a high ball played into the penalty area that is caught by the goalkeeper. We face the same issue as saves in that there are more opportunities for keepers to make saves when their opponents play more highballs into the box. Also, it can be a good decision when a keeper does not attempt to claim a cross if their defender is going to deal with it more comfortably, or if staying on his line means he has a higher chance of making a subsequent save.

The Top 5 keepers for catches are:

  • 59 - Keet

  • 35 - Nyame

  • 34 - Magoola

  • 29 - Nwabali, Sapunga

Stephens (23) is the only Goalkeeper of the Season nominee in the Top 10 here, with Williams (11th) and Sangare (18th) lower down. Interestingly, Nwabali & Sapunga also lead the league for punches (high balls cleared with a clenched fist and not claimed), with Sangare (6th) & Stephens (10th) the only nominees in the Top 10.

Sweeping

Sweeping is another aspect of goalkeeping that is measured by modern-day data collectors and can be looked at. A “sweep” is defined by OPTA as “any time a goalkeeper anticipates danger and rushes off their line to try to either cut out an attacking pass (in a race with the opposition player) or to close down an opposition player.”

  • The keeper must rush out to at least the edge of their area.

  • There must be at least some pressure from the opposition player racing to the ball

  • The keeper must react quickly and read the play

While occurring less frequently than saves (average 3 per game for the highest) and also catches (2 per game for the highest), keeper sweepings (1 per game for the highest) are still a very valuable skill. By definition alone, sweepings involve anticipation, sensing danger, and reacting quickly to it.

The Top 5 keepers for accurate keeper sweepings:

  • 27 - Nwabali

  • 21 - Williams

  • 19 - Goss

  • 16 - Keet

  • 10 - Magoola, Mothwa

    • Stephens (11th), Sangare (17th)

In-possession

The days when goalkeepers simply launched every goal kick upfield to the “big man” are slowly becoming extinct. Keepers can get up to 10 goal-kicks a game, so they are a valuable asset if used wisely. Modern-day goalkeepers are increasingly being asked to help build up play from the back, through short passes, line-breaking passes, and more. This is true at some clubs more than others - it’s crazy to consider that Ronwen Williams is in the Top 30 for accurate passes played among all players in the league (including outfield players - about 500 players have at least 90 minutes under their belt). But where do other keepers rank:

Top 5 for most successful passes (pass accuracy in brackets):

  • 796 - Williams (86%)

  • 545 - Akpeyi (73%)

  • 505 - Keet (67%)

  • 495 - Nwabali (65%)

  • 442 - Goss (55%)

    • Stephens (8th), Sangare (9th)

Errors

The life of a goalkeeper can also be one of the harshest on the field. One moment you’re making acrobatic saves; the next you’re destined for the Bloopers real. Whereas outfield players’ errors often go unpunished, errors by goalkeepers can prove fatal. Thrice this season, Ronwen Williams & Salim Magoola committed errors leading to shots (the most of all keepers). None of these led to a goal for Williams, but one ended up as a goal for Magoola. Melusi Buthelezi, meanwhile, was the only keeper with more than one error leading to a goal (2). It’s all a rather thin read here, but there are more instances of drops (a high ball where the goalkeeper tries to catch the ball, and gets his hands on the ball but it drops from their grasp.)

Most drops by a keeper this season:

  • 7 - Nwabali, Magoola

  • 6 - Mothwa, Boshoff

  • 5 - Mpoto

    • Sangare (3), Stephens (3), Williams (1)

Future Analysis

We tried to go beyond clean sheets and saves, but even in doing that we’ve merely scratched the surface. Consideration is needed on what coaches ask keepers (like outfielders) to do in & out of possession while judging them. Goals prevented, post-shot xG, difficulty of shots faced, speed of shots faced, and keeper reflexes are all measurable in today’s world and can enrich performance analysis. There were some mind-boggling saves from Sage Stephens we witnessed in person that may not get the recognition they deserve until we look deeper under the bonnet. A Sipho Chaine may not appear in the passing stats, but when considering the success of passes ending in the opposition's final third, he is the league leader. The value of keeper passes can be scrutinised, including how they pass under pressure, how often they break defensive lines and more. This would need access to deeper data and more time to analyse, both of which can only be possible with your support of our work.

Get the Laduma Analytics newsletter

PSL analysis like this in your inbox. Subscribe free

More articles

  • Zones of Control
    (Yet) another way to measure “dominance”? Fri 20 Nov 2026 · 4 min read
  • Milford FC and Kruger United adjust.
    How the newly promoted teams are finding their feet in the top flight. Sat 7 Nov 2026 · 5 min read
  • Soweto derby preview..
    Pirates host Chiefs as defensive numbers cross for the first time in 26 years. Sat 31 Oct 2026 · 4 min read
  • Ocean’s Eleven
    Measuring attacking involvement beyond goals and assists. Sat 24 Oct 2026 · 6 min read
  • PSL Progress Report
    How PSL teams are performing in both boxes compared to last season? Sat 17 Oct 2026 · 4 min read

All articles