The recently ended PSL saw new clean sheet record set at individual goalkeeper level, as Sipho Chaine shattered the existing record, adding three clean sheets. At club level, his team Orlando Pirates also equalled the PSL record for clean sheets in a single PSL campaign (21 in 30). Darren Keet (12), Ronwen Williams (13), Ricardo Goss (14), Brandon Petersen (15) and Sipho Chaine (21) were the top clean-sheet keepers all season, and the only players with than 10. It would not be a surprise if the three Goalkeeper of the Season nominees come from this, which would trigger a new debate on which goalkeeper had the best season. The debate has spilled over into national team selection, with four of the five in contention for the upcoming World Cup. In the end, Williams, Goss and Chaine were chosen. In this piece, we look at some numbers behind the five goalkeepers who had 10 or more clean sheets.
1. Clean sheets
While clean sheets are a go-to starting point, they should merely open the discussion, not close it. There is more to being a keeper than just stopping shots - organising your backline, offering a ‘third eye’ option to defenders, playing as a sweeper and building up play all matter. Some clean sheets owe more to defenders’ heroics than keepers, and some can be achieved without a keeper being tested 24 times this season, a keeper kept a clean sheet without facing a single shot on target. That said, keepers also deserve credit for pressuring attackers into bad/wayward shots. On many levels, the clean sheet argument can be picked at, but remains a common benchmark for goalkeepers.
Top five keepers for clean sheets in the league this season:
21 - Sipho Chaine (70% clean sheet rate - 21 in 30)
15 - Brandon Petersen (63%)
14 - Ricardo Goss (48%)
13 - Ronwen Williams (45%)
12 - Darren Keet (44%)
2. Frequency of goals conceded
Chaine conceded just 12 goals all season, with Petersen slightly behind on 13. However, Petersen played significantly fewer minutes after picking up an injury earlier in the year. Would he have conceded more goals if he played more? Would he have kept more clean sheets in the six games he missed? These are hypotheticals, but goals conceded per 90 levels the playing field. Minutes per goal conceded is a similar proxy.
Ranking by goals conceded per 90:
Chaine: 0.4 goals per 90 minutes
Petersen: 0.54
Williams: 0.72
Goss & Keet - 0.9
Ranking by minutes per goal conceded:
Chaine - 225 minutes for every goal conceded [one goal every 2-and-a-half games]
Petersen - 166 mins
Williams - 124 mins
Goss & Keet - 100 mins
3. Shot stopping
Saves remain a key measure for assessing goalkeepers, but even these have their limits. Save volumes (like many defensive metrics), depend heavily on opponent actions, and different teams prioritise different defending objectives. A team playing a high defensive line, for example, will likely win more offsides and concede fewer shots (i.e opportunities for the keeper to save). Yet, the quality of shots the keeper faces will mostly be high, given a high proportion of chances can be conceded on fast breaks.
Ranking by saves this season:
77 - Goss
62 - Keet
47 - Petersen
46 - Williams
40 - Chaine
Ranking by save percentage (shots on target faced in brackets):
78% - Petersen (59 shots on target faced)
77% - Chaine (52)
75% - Goss (102)
71% - Keet (84)
68% - Williams (62)
Most of these are fine margins. Before conceding eight goals in his last three games of the season, Williams was sitting on 76%, which fell sharply in seven days.
4. Aerial Ability
Beyond saves, how keepers perform under high balls is another metric to consider. The OPTA definition for a catch is simple:
a high ball into the penalty area caught cleanly.
Again, opposition crossing habits will influence opportunities here. Teams may avoid too many high crosses when facing keepers they believe are good in the air.
Most catches:
39 - Keet
21 - Goss
19 - Williams
14 - Chaine
10 - Petersen
Petersen's injury clouds a lot. His rate-based numbers (63% clean sheet rate, 0.54 goals/90 and 78% save percentage) suggest he was the equal of Chaine in some metrics across the time he played.
5. Sweeping
A sweep is defined as any time a keeper anticipates danger and rushes off their line to cut out an attacking pass or close down an opposition player. For it to count, the keeper must advance at least to the edge of their area, react quickly, and face genuine pressure from an onrushing opponent.
Ranking by accurate keeper sweepings (sweep accuracy in brackets)
21 - Williams (91% keeper sweeper accuracy: successful sweeps divided by attempts).
19 - Goss (95%)
11 - Keet (92%)
7 - Chaine (100%)
6 - Petersen (100%)
7. On The Ball
The modern keeper is now considered an integral part of team build-up, capable of initiating attacking moves from the back. Williams even features in the top 10 players for passes completed across the league (including outfielders), with Chaine in the Top 25. Some game states at the World Cup may need good passing from the back.
Ranking by successful passes (pass accuracy in brackets):
1,104 - Williams (89% accuracy)
850 - Chaine (84%)
724 - Goss (67%)
423 - Keet (62%)
393 - Petersen (74%)
8. Errors
Between the five keepers, only Keet and Williams had errors directly leading to a goal - two each. The stat considers obvious mistakes attributable to a goalkeeper, not subjective calls like poor positioning or defensive miscommunications. All keepers had drops this season (“a high ball where the keeper tries to catch the ball, and gets his hands on the ball, but it drops from their grasp”), but even here, the margins are narrow.
Ranking these keepers by how often they drop the ball:
5 times - Keet
3 times - Chaine, Petersen
2 times - Goss, Williams
What is clear is that no single keeper dominates across every metric. Chaine leads on clean sheets and goals conceded, Petersen edges everyone on save percentage, Williams is in a class of his own with the ball at his feet and off his line, while Goss was the busiest of the options. That is part of what makes the Goalkeeper of the Season conversation difficult to settle, and why reducing it to clean sheets alone does a disservice to all the goalkeepers.

